ARCHIVES, OPINION

OPINION | Attention, City Hall: Enough is enough

Biddeford’s leaders need to stop treating taxpayers like an endless piggy bank. We demand accountability and sound financial management practices

By TAMMY BELANGER | Gazette Columnist

There comes a point when enough is enough. For many Biddeford taxpayers, I believe we have reached that point.

I have lived in Biddeford for decades, raised my family here, owned a home, and operated a small business. I love this city and want to see it succeed. But loving your community doesn’t mean blindly accepting every spending decision made at City Hall, especially when the people footing the bill are increasingly struggling to afford their own lives.

Property taxes, insurance, groceries, utilities, and just about everything else continue to rise. Unlike municipal government, residents cannot simply increase their revenue whenever their expenses exceed their income.

We have to make choices. Sometimes difficult ones.

Why should we expect anything less from the people managing our tax dollars?

CITY COUNCILORS LISA VADNAIS AND ROGER BEAUPRE make their choices for top priority picks during a recent city council workshop intended to define and prioritize the council’s goals for the coming year | Biddeford Gazette file photo

Let’s talk about priorities, starting with the people who actually pay the bills.

Biddeford has experienced tremendous redevelopment, particularly downtown. Some of that growth has been wonderful to see. But I think it’s time we take a serious look at the city’s Tax Increment Financing agreements, commonly known as TIFs.

TIFs can be useful economic development tools, but they also involve financial trade-offs. Depending on how they are structured, certain property tax revenues are captured for designated purposes rather than becoming available for general municipal spending.

I would like to see a comprehensive, publicly accessible accounting of every active TIF agreement in Biddeford. How much revenue is being captured? Where is that money going? What obligations have we made, and what measurable financial benefits are ordinary taxpayers receiving?

I understand that TIFs can have legitimate economic and state-aid benefits. But those benefits should be clearly demonstrated, not simply assumed.

Economic development is important, but what good is a revitalized city if the people who helped build it can no longer afford to live here?

DOWNTOWN BIDDEFORD | Biddeford Gazette File Photo

And then there is the city’s financial management.

The ongoing problems with overdue audits should be deeply concerning to every taxpayer. An audit isn’t simply paperwork. It provides independent verification of financial statements and helps identify weaknesses in financial controls.

How are residents supposed to have confidence in long-term spending decisions when the city’s financial reporting has fallen so far behind?

I wouldn’t operate my household or business without regularly reconciling my accounts and understanding my financial obligations. I certainly wouldn’t keep adding new expenses without knowing whether I could afford them.

Why should City Hall operate under a different standard?

I believe there should be a temporary moratorium on new discretionary programs and initiatives until the outstanding audits are completed and the city has presented a clear, credible financial plan.

That should be accompanied by a freeze on nonessential hiring, stricter controls on overtime, and a serious examination of existing positions and departmental expenses. Essential public safety services, legally required obligations, and genuine emergencies would obviously need exceptions.

And while we’re examining staffing and departmental expenses, let’s address another issue: employee work hours.

If a city employee is being paid for a 40-hour workweek, then taxpayers should reasonably expect 40 hours of work. Not 35 hours, not a shortened schedule simply because that’s how things have always been done. In the private sector, employees are generally expected to work the hours outlined in their employment agreements. Why should municipal employment be any different?

I’m not suggesting that city employees aren’t hardworking or dedicated. Many absolutely are. But taxpayers deserve transparency about staffing schedules, paid hours, actual hours worked, and the policies governing them. If employees are contracted and compensated for 35 hours, that’s a different discussion. But if taxpayers are funding 40-hour positions, those hours should be accounted for.

Accountability shouldn’t stop at the department budget. It should extend to how taxpayer-funded work hours are managed.

And yes, I believe meaningful spending cuts need to be on the table.

Not just moving money around or trimming a few dollars here and there to make a budget appear more palatable.

Real cuts. Real priorities. Real accountability.

BIDDEFORD MAYOR LIAM LAFOUNTAIN indicates his priorities for the coming year | Biddeford Gazette photo by Randy Seaver

That means every department and every taxpayer-funded program should be reviewed. No automatic renewals simply because something has always been funded. No assumption that last year’s budget should automatically become the starting point for an even larger budget this year.

Every expenditure should have to justify its value to the taxpayers.

Will that be painful? Probably. Will everyone agree on what should be cut? Absolutely not.

But that is precisely why we elect people to make difficult decisions.

I am not advocating that we abandon essential services. Police, fire, public works, and maintaining our existing infrastructure are fundamental responsibilities of city government. But there is a significant difference between providing necessary services and continually expanding government beyond what its residents can reasonably afford.

I also recognize that the current mayor and council inherited some serious financial and administrative challenges. Efforts have been made to address those problems, and I believe those efforts deserve acknowledgment.

But there comes a time when recognizing the problems is no longer enough. Residents need to see measurable progress and meaningful results.

For too long, taxpayers have attended meetings, written letters, asked questions, and expressed frustration about rising costs. Yet the conversation inevitably seems to return to what the city needs, what departments need, and what programs need.

When does the conversation turn to what the taxpayers can actually afford?

I would like to see the city approach its next budget with a different philosophy. Instead of starting with what every department wants and figuring out how much more taxpayers must contribute, start with a realistic spending target based on the financial capacity of the community.

Prioritize the essentials. Examine every discretionary expense. Review employee contracts, staffing schedules, and actual hours worked. Identify efficiencies. Require justification for increases. And when the numbers don’t work, make the difficult decisions necessary to bring spending under control.

Residents do this every day.

We postpone home repairs, drive our vehicles a little longer, cut back on entertainment, and reconsider purchases because our budgets demand it. Small business owners make those same decisions, sometimes sacrificing their own income to keep their businesses operating.

There comes a time when recognizing
the problems is no longer enough.

We don’t have a bottomless piggy bank.

Neither should City Hall.

I want Biddeford to prosper. I want a vibrant downtown, thriving businesses, safe neighborhoods, good schools, and a community that future generations will be proud to call home.

But prosperity cannot be measured solely by new buildings, development projects, or the number of programs a city offers.

It must also be measured by whether the people who live here can afford to stay.

And I would remind our elected officials and city administrators of something that should never be forgotten:

You work for the residents of Biddeford. We do not work for you.

That doesn’t mean every resident will agree with every decision. It does mean taxpayers deserve honest answers, responsible financial management, transparency, and leadership willing to make difficult choices rather than continually passing the financial burden along to residents.

It’s time to stop treating property owners as an endless source of additional revenue.

Biddeford needs to learn to live within its means, because its residents are running out of ways to stretch theirs.


Tammy Belanger

ABOUT THE AUTHOR | Tammy Belanger is a regular columnist for the Biddeford Gazette, covering City Hall and other public policy issues impacting the city. She is a longtime Biddeford resident, small business owner, photographer and dog lover. “I am a wife and a mother of three adults who were raised here. I care deeply about our community, and the people who live here,” she says.


The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of the Biddeford Gazette, its staff, affiliates or sponsors. We encourage robust and diverse community conversations on topics related to the city of Biddeford. To submit your own letter or column, please CONTACT US

6 Comments

  1. Jack Parenteau's avatar Jack Parenteau

    What a well written opinion. It applies not only to Biddeford, but I would say the same things apply to City and Town governments across this country. It also applies to our federal government which seems to think citizens are a bottomless pit. While I no longer live in Biddeford, I keep abreast with everything Biddeford, and love the well written o0inions and articles from the Biddeford Gazette.

  2. Outstanding piece. As a Saco taxpayer, the same approach is desperately needed in Saco

  3. Maureen Redmond's avatar Maureen Redmond

    Point on…..!!!

  4. Very well written Tammy !!

  5. Well written Tammy . It’s always easier to spend someone else’s money . Increasing taxes is always the easiest way out .As elected officials tough decisions need to be made .

  6. Kenneth buechs's avatar Kenneth buechs

    I support two of the major points here. The first is a picture board of every TIF-related project, including the expected infra-structure costs.. The second is zero-based budgeting every year: where each cost center must justify baseline costs and differential costs for the new fiscal year with justification.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*